From 9 July, if you sell to customers in the United States, there’s a new cost landing on your table — and you didn’t get a vote. Etsy now asks sellers shipping into the US to cover import duties upfront, under what’s called Delivered Duty Paid. If you want your orders protected, the duty comes out of your pricing, not out of a nasty surprise for the customer at their front door.
But here’s the thing. This isn’t really a story about Etsy, or America, or duties. It’s a lesson in pricing for rising costs — and the makers who shrug this one off are the ones who priced with room to absorb it in the first place.
The cost you didn’t choose is the one that catches you out
Every maker plans for the costs she can see. Materials, packaging, her own time — they go into the price, or at least they should. The costs that actually hurt are the ones handed to you: a platform fee rise, a courier increase, a new duty, a supplier putting materials up twelve per cent overnight.
You can’t stop any of it. What you can control is whether your price has the give to take the hit without you quietly eating it. And that’s the bit most makers miss. When the margin is thin, every cost rise is really a pay cut — it just doesn’t feel like one until you look at the numbers.
A ×2 price has no give. A ×4 price does.
Think about what your price is actually built on. If you’re charging twice what a product truly costs you to make, you’re sitting at survival — covering costs and paying yourself, with nothing spare. So the moment a duty or a fee lands, you’re underwater.
Price at three to four times your true cost, though, and you’ve built yourself a shock absorber. That headroom was never about greed. It’s resilience. It’s the difference between saying “yes, costs went up, and I’m fine” and scrambling to work out how to stay afloat. On top of that, a small contingency — around five per cent — built into every price covers exactly this: the variance, the surprise, the thing you didn’t see coming.
How to price for rising costs without guessing
Before you react to any cost change, get the real number. Work out what it actually adds per item. For the new US duty, that means the duty rate on your product category, per order — not a vague sense of “more expensive now”. Then hold that against your margin and see whether your buffer already covers it or whether you’ve just started selling under cost.
Here’s a rule of thumb makers use: if a cost shifts your unit cost by more than about five per cent, it’s time to look at your price. Under that, your buffer should quietly absorb it. Either way, it’s a five-minute sum, not a crisis. So do the sum first — panic never.
Raising your price is not the disaster you’re picturing
This is where most makers freeze. You assume that the second you raise a price, customers will walk. In reality, they mostly don’t. Plenty of makers raise prices and see orders hold steady — and some see them go up, because a higher price quietly signals a better product.
You also don’t have to make one dramatic leap. Small, steady increases over time read as normal, the way everything else creeps up. And when a customer does ask, “costs have gone up” is a complete sentence. No apology, no paragraph of justification. Remember too that losing a few customers at the right price isn’t failure — it’s selection. The ones who stay at the correct price are worth far more than a longer list at the wrong one.
The bottom line
You will never control the fees, the duties, the couriers or the cost of your materials. There’s always a next change coming, and it’s never going to ask your permission. What you do control is the margin you build in before any of it lands. So price for the business you want to still have after the next surprise — not the one that just about survives the last one.
