If you’re selling handmade and trying to move into a more premium price point, the conversation almost always comes back to materials. Sourcing premium materials for your handmade business is one of the strongest positioning levers you’ve got — but it’s also one of the easiest places to wreck your margin if you go in without a plan.
The bag isn’t just leather, it’s the leather. The candle isn’t just soy, it’s the wax, the wick, the fragrance house, the vessel. Your materials are doing more work than most makers give them credit for.
So this is the bit nobody wants to spell out: better materials don’t automatically mean better margins. They can wreck your numbers if you don’t think it through properly. But used well, they become one of the strongest levers you have for premium positioning, supplier leverage, and the kind of repeat customer who’ll pay your prices without flinching.
Here’s what to actually do.
What counts as a ‘premium’ material in a handmade business?
A premium material is one where the quality, provenance, or scarcity is genuinely better than what most competitors at your price point are using, and where you can point to why. It’s not a label. It’s a measurable difference your customer can feel, see, or verify.
In practice, that usually means one of three things. First, the material itself is higher grade — full-grain leather instead of bonded, single-origin essential oils instead of generic fragrance, 9ct gold instead of plated. Second, the source is traceable and tells a story — a small UK mill, a named tannery, a specific farm. Third, it’s harder to get — limited runs, seasonal availability, or relationships you’ve built that competitors haven’t.
If you can’t tell a customer specifically what makes the material better, it isn’t premium yet. It’s just more expensive.
Where do you find suppliers when you’re sourcing premium materials for a handmade business?
Start with the suppliers your competitors aren’t using. The big wholesale platforms are useful for getting started, but everyone’s there. To stand out, you need to find suppliers who don’t show up on the first page of Google — trade-only mills, small importers, regional producers, and the suppliers used by brands one or two tiers above yours.
A few places that actually work:
- Trade shows in your specific category — not the big consumer ones, the buyer-only ones. For UK makers, that’s events like Top Drawer or Pulse for product, and dedicated material shows like Première Vision for textiles.
- Trade association directories. Most material categories have one. Membership often gives you access to a supplier list that isn’t public.
- The credits page on a brand you admire. If they list their suppliers, you’ve got a starting point. If they don’t, look at their materials, identify the most likely supplier type, and search for that.
- Industry-specific Facebook groups and forums. Not the general maker groups — the specialist ones where the supplier conversations actually happen.
Once you’ve got a shortlist, request samples from at least three suppliers per material. Pay for samples if you have to. The cost of three sample sets is nothing compared to ordering bulk from the wrong supplier.
How do you vet a supplier before you commit?
Vetting a supplier means checking quality, consistency, and reliability before you put serious money through them. The minimum test is: order samples, ask for references, check their lead times against your production schedule, and run a small first order before committing to anything bigger. If they can’t handle a small order well, they won’t handle a big one.
Beyond that, there are a few things worth asking directly, even if it feels nosy:
- Where does this material actually come from? Not the country it ships from — the country it’s made in. These are often different.
- What’s your typical lead time, and what happens if you miss it? A supplier who won’t put lead time commitments in writing isn’t worth the headache.
- Can I see your most recent quality certificates? Industries that require certification (food contact, cosmetics, children’s products) make this non-negotiable.
- Who else do you supply? They won’t always tell you, but the answer reveals a lot about where they sit in the market.
And test reliability with the small things first. Did they respond to your enquiry within a working day? Was the sample where they said it would be, when they said it would be? Could they remember what you asked for? Small inconsistencies become big ones at scale.
How much should premium materials cost as a percentage of your retail price?
Aim for materials to land between 15% and 30% of your retail price for a premium handmade product. Lower than 15% and you’re either underpriced or using cheaper materials than your positioning suggests. Higher than 30% and your margin is too thin to absorb wholesale, marketing costs, or any kind of growth.
This is where most makers come unstuck when they upgrade materials. You swap to a better leather, double your material cost, and forget to adjust your retail price. Or you adjust it once and never again as the material price creeps up over the next two years. Then you wonder why your business feels harder, not easier.
If you’re upgrading materials, do the maths properly before you commit. Work out the new cost of goods, your target margin, and what that means for your retail price. If the price increase feels too big, that’s useful information — either the material isn’t right for your current positioning, or your current positioning needs to move.
How do you build a relationship with a premium supplier so they prioritise you?
Pay on time, every time. Communicate clearly. Place consistent orders rather than feast-and-famine. That’s the foundation. After 12 months of being a reliable, easy customer, most suppliers will start giving you priority on stock, early access to new ranges, and better terms — without you ever asking.
What this looks like in practice is treating suppliers like business partners rather than vendors. Tell them what you’re working on. Share your forecast for the year, even roughly. Ask their advice on materials when you’re developing something new — they often know about products you’ve never heard of, because they hear about them from their other customers.
The makers who get the best material deals aren’t the ones who haggle hardest. They’re the ones who become the customer suppliers want to keep.
The bottom line
Sourcing premium materials for your handmade business isn’t about chasing the most expensive option you can find. It’s about choosing materials that justify your price, building supplier relationships that protect your margin, and knowing the difference between premium and just expensive. Get that right and your materials become a quiet competitive advantage. Get it wrong and they become an expensive lesson.
If your brand feels a bit patchy or you’re not sure your materials are actually saying what you want them to say at your price point, the Creative Brand Codex™ walks you through the whole brand audit positioning, materials, messaging, the lot. It’s only £297 and you can work through it at your own pace.