The True Stall Cost
I once drove ninety minutes each way to a Christmas fair, took £612, and spent the entire journey home telling my husband it was the best day I’d had all year.
It was the best day I’d had all year. It also lost money. It took me another three years to work out that both of those things were true at the same time.
The sum I did in the car is the sum everyone does. Six hundred and twelve pounds, less the forty-five quid stall fee. Call it £567 and a very good Saturday. I did that arithmetic somewhere around junction 21 and never thought about it again, which is precisely the problem.
Why craft fair profit is almost never what you think
Takings minus stall fee is the most flattering sum available to a maker, and we reach for it because it reliably produces a number we like. It also ignores the two largest costs of the day, both of which are invisible because neither of them arrives as a receipt.
The first is getting there. The second is the hours, and the hours are enormous.
Nobody is trying to mislead anyone here. It’s simply that the stall fee is the only cost with an invoice attached, so it’s the only cost that feels real. Everything else… the fuel, the Friday night packing, the Sunday spent relisting what came home, happens quietly and gets absorbed into the general condition of being self-employed.
The True Stall Cost
Four numbers. Not one.
The stall fee. The easy one.
Travel and cover. Fuel at a real rate, parking, and whatever it cost to have someone else do what you’d normally be doing — childcare, a paid helper, the day your partner took off.
Your hours. All of them. The packing the night before. The drive. The setup. The day itself. The pack-down. The admin on Sunday when you relist the stock and reconcile the takings. Charge them at a rate you’d accept from anyone else, because you’d never work a sixteen-hour day for another business without asking.
The making hours inside the stock you sold. Those pieces cost you time before they ever reached the table, and that time came out of the same finite quarter as everything else.
Then divide the money you actually kept by the hours it actually took.
Two of those four will make you uncomfortable, and they’re the two that matter. Makers routinely undercount the hours by half, because we only count the trading day, the seven hours behind the table feel like the event, and the other ten feel like life. They aren’t. Nobody packed a car at eleven at night for fun. And almost nobody counts the making hours at all, on the reasoning that the stock existed already, which is true and beside the point: it existed because you made it, and you made it instead of something else.
Here’s my £612 day, done properly.
| Takings | £612 |
| Materials in the 22 pieces sold | −£190 |
| Stall fee | −£45 |
| Travel: 118 miles at 45p, plus £8 parking | −£61 |
| Kept | £316 |
| Event hours: pack 3, drive 3, setup 1.5, trade 7, pack-down 1, admin 2 | 17.5 hrs |
| Making hours in the 22 pieces sold | 26.4 hrs |
| Total hours | 43.9 hrs |
| Per hour | £7.20 |
Seven pounds twenty. On my best day of the year.
And that’s the generous version, because I carried sixty pieces and thirty-eight came home another forty-five hours of my life sitting in a box waiting for a second chance at a table somewhere.
The comparison that actually stings is the one against the alternative. At the £12.40 an hour my bestseller was earning me at the time, those same 43.9 hours spent making and selling online would have returned about £544. The fair didn’t just underpay me. It cost me roughly £228 against what I’d have earned staying at home in my pyjamas.
What this does not mean
It does not mean stop doing fairs. I still do them, and I’d argue anyone selling handmade should.
What it means is that a fair is a channel with a cost, like any other, and you have to know the cost before you can judge the day. Right now most makers are judging fairs on how the day felt, which is roughly as reliable as judging a business on how busy you are.
Because fairs do things a spreadsheet won’t capture. You meet people. You watch strangers pick things up and put them down, which teaches you more about your range in four hours than four months of analytics. You collect email addresses. You get wholesale enquiries and commissions and the woman who comes back every year and brings her sister.
All of which is real. But it only counts if you count it.
That £228 gap looks like a loss right up until the moment you notice I collected sixty email addresses that day. Suddenly it’s £3.80 a subscriber, which is cheaper than any advertising I have ever bought, and the day was excellent value — as a list-building exercise that happened to also take £612.
A fair that loses £228 and builds your list is an investment. A fair that loses £228 and does nothing else is a hobby with a table and a long drive.
So decide the second job before you book, not afterwards. Is this event for cash, for the list, for wholesale leads, or for testing a new range in front of people who’ll tell you the truth with their faces? Write it down. Then measure the day against the job you gave it rather than against the takings, which is the number that happens to be easiest to count and tells you the least.
When the number is bad
Three responses, and grinding harder isn’t one of them.
Charge fair prices at fairs. Not lower than online. Never lower than online, and if you’ve been quietly knocking a fiver off to be nice, that fiver is coming directly out of the £7.20.
Carry less stock. Thirty-eight pieces came home. Every one represented hours I could have spent on something already sold. Most makers overpack out of anxiety and pay for it in a currency they never count.
Or stop booking the ones below your floor. Decide what an hour of your time has to return, run last year’s events through the sum, and let the numbers choose next year’s calendar instead of the memory of which ones felt busy.
But I like doing fairs
Good. So do I. It’s a legitimate reason to do something, and I’m not interested in the version of business advice where every hour has to justify itself in a spreadsheet.
But there’s a difference between a fair you do knowing it returns £7.20 an hour and sixty email addresses, and a fair you do because last year felt busy. The first is a decision. The second is a habit that costs you a weekend.
Owners book the fairs that pay, in whatever currency they’ve decided counts. Makers book the fairs they enjoyed and find out in January.
This week: take the last fair you did and write down four numbers, stall fee, travel, your hours, and the making hours in what sold. Divide what you kept by the hours. One sum, ten minutes.
I still do this after every event. It takes about ten minutes and I’ve never once enjoyed the answer, which is a reasonable description of most useful management information.
What changed for me wasn’t that I stopped doing fairs. It’s that I do about a third as many, at better events, with less stock and higher prices, and I know before I book what each one has to deliver to be worth the drive. I enjoy them considerably more now, and I don’t think that’s a coincidence.
See you at the desk next week.
Nic

